Head to head · Southeast Asia's two great island trips
Philippines vs Thailand: Which Is Better for Islands and Nature?
Short answer: choose Thailand for an easy island-and-karst trip from one base — Phang Nga Bay, Railay and the Similan Islands are all within half a day of Phuket or Krabi, best from November to April. Choose the Philippines for more, and wilder, variety — El Nido's lagoons, Coron's Kayangan Lake, the Tubbataha reefs, whale sharks at Donsol, the Chocolate Hills and the Banaue rice terraces — if you are willing to fly between islands.
Both have the limestone seascape the region is famous for: Thailand's Phang Nga Bay and Railay, the Philippines' El Nido and Coron in northern Palawan. Both are dry-season trips, with the rains and rougher seas roughly from June to October, but the windows differ a little: Thailand's Andaman coast is best November to April, El Nido December to May, Coron late October to May.
Diving splits them. Thailand's Similans are open roughly mid-October to mid-May, by day boat or liveaboard from Khao Lak. The Philippines' Tubbataha Reefs open only from mid-March to mid-June, liveaboard only from Puerto Princesa — but you can also swim with a resident sardine school at Moalboal and with whale sharks at Donsol.
Philippines
Lagoons, reefs and island-hopping across an archipelago
A spread-out archipelago trip. In Palawan: El Nido's Bacuit Archipelago, with lagoons reached through rock gaps on the standard island-hopping tours; Kayangan Lake on Coron Island; the 8.2 km navigable Puerto Princesa Underground River (permit and daily cap); and the Tubbataha Reefs, liveaboard-only in a short mid-March to mid-June window. Elsewhere: the 1,200-plus Chocolate Hills of Bohol, brown from late February to May; the Moalboal sardine run and Kawasan Falls on Cebu; whale sharks at Donsol, roughly December to May; and the 2,000-year-old Banaue terraces, 8–9 hours north of Manila.
- Karst lagoons at El Nido and Coron, with more island-hopping than one trip can hold
- Tubbataha's remote reefs, the Moalboal sardine run and whale sharks at Donsol
- Land wonders too: the Chocolate Hills, the Banaue terraces and an underground river
Thailand
The Andaman coast, compact and easy
A coast-first nature trip from Phuket or Krabi: Phang Nga Bay's karst islands and sea-cave lagoons, explored by boat and sea kayak; Railay, a cliff-walled peninsula reached only by longtail boat and one of the world's great rock-climbing spots; and the Similan Islands, eleven granite islands widely rated the best diving in Thailand, about 1.5 hours by speedboat from Khao Lak. Inland, Erawan's seven tiers of emerald pools are a long day trip from Bangkok.
- Phang Nga Bay, Railay and the Similans all within half a day of Phuket or Krabi
- The Similans by day trip or liveaboard, with whale sharks and mantas in March–April
- Rock climbing at Railay
Head to head
| What matters | Philippines | Thailand |
|---|---|---|
| Karst seascape Edge: Toss-up | El Nido's Bacuit Archipelago — dozens of limestone islands and hidden lagoons — and Kayangan Lake on Coron Island. | Phang Nga Bay's sheer karst islands and tidal lagoons, and the cliff-walled beaches of Railay. |
| Diving and snorkelling Edge: Philippines | Tubbataha (liveaboard only, mid-March to mid-June), the sardine school a few strokes from shore at Moalboal, and Apo Reef. | The Similans' granite boulder dives, plus excellent snorkelling on their sheltered east sides; open roughly mid-October to mid-May. |
| Swimming with whale sharks Edge: Philippines | Donsol in Bicol, roughly December to May, peaking February to April, on regulated community-run trips. | Whale sharks pass through the Similans, most often in March and April. |
| Land wonders Edge: Philippines | The Chocolate Hills of Bohol, the Banaue rice terraces, the Puerto Princesa Underground River and Kawasan Falls. | Erawan's seven-tiered falls, a long day trip from Bangkok via Kanchanaburi. |
| Getting around Edge: Thailand | By domestic flights and long transfers: El Nido is 5–6 hours by van from Puerto Princesa if you don't fly in, Banaue 8–9 hours by bus from Manila, Tubbataha 5–7 nights by liveaboard. | Compact: Phang Nga Bay, Railay and the Similan boats are all reached from Phuket, Krabi or Khao Lak. |
| Best months Edge: Toss-up | Roughly December to May for Palawan (El Nido peak March–May), late February to May for the brown Chocolate Hills, mid-March to mid-June for Tubbataha. | November to April for the whole Andaman coast; February to April for the calmest seas at the Similans. |
| June to October Edge: Toss-up | Rain and rougher seas in Palawan; the Underground River crossing can close at short notice. Moalboal, on Cebu's sheltered west coast, is good year-round. | The southwest monsoon on the Andaman coast; the Similans are closed. |
Which should you choose?
Choose Philippines if…
…you want the widest range of island, reef and land wonders, are a diver or snorkeller, and don't mind domestic flights and long transfers.
Choose Thailand if…
…you want karst islands, beaches and diving from one easy base, are short on time, and are travelling between November and April.
The honest verdict
Thailand is the easier trip: Phang Nga Bay, Railay and the Similan Islands are all a short hop from Phuket or Krabi, and the whole Andaman coast is at its best from November to April.
The Philippines is the bigger nature trip: El Nido and Coron match Thailand's karst seascape, and it adds what Thailand's list doesn't — Tubbataha, the Moalboal sardines, whale sharks at Donsol, the Chocolate Hills and Banaue's terraces. The cost is time spent getting between islands.
If the choice is just karst bay against karst bay, see our Railay vs El Nido comparison.
Wonders mentioned here
Added