Head to head · America's two deepest lakes
Lake Tahoe vs Crater Lake: Which Deep Blue Lake Should You Visit?
Lake Tahoe and Crater Lake are the two deepest lakes in the United States, and both are famous for blue, clear water. Crater Lake, in southern Oregon, is the deepest at 594 m (about 1,950 ft); it fills the caldera of Mount Mazama, which erupted and collapsed some 7,700 years ago, and no river flows in or out. Lake Tahoe, on the California–Nevada border, is second at 1,645 ft (501 m), but far larger: 22 miles long and 11 miles wide, with 192 square miles of surface fed by 63 streams.
They are very different trips. Crater Lake is a national park you mostly see from the rim, with one steep trail to the water and a short summer season. Tahoe is a lived-in lake ringed by towns, where you can swim, paddle and drive the shore, and Emerald Bay is the classic view.
Lake Tahoe
A vast alpine lake you can swim, paddle and drive around
At about 6,223 ft in the Sierra Nevada, about 2 million years old and drained only by the Truckee River. Its clarity fell from about 100 ft in 1968 to about 64 ft in 1997 and has since steadied around 65 ft; a federal plan aims for 97.4 ft by 2076. Emerald Bay State Park, on Highway 89 22 miles south of Tahoe City, has the famous view of Fannette Island and a 1-mile, 500-ft trail down to Vikingsholm. About 3 million people visit a year.
- Swimming, paddling and beaches — summer surface water averages about 68°F
- Towns, lodging and services all around the shore
- Emerald Bay and the Vikingsholm trail
- Year-round recreation, not just a summer season
Crater Lake
A volcanic caldera of almost unreal blue
Rain and snowmelt alone fill the caldera, and the pure, deep water absorbs almost every colour except an intense blue. Cliffs up to 600 m ring the lake and Wizard Island's cinder cone breaks the surface. The Rim Drive circles the caldera when it is open, but heavy snow closes most of it and the north entrance for much of the year, commonly from around October until June or July. The Cleetwood Cove trail is the only legal route down to the water, and boat tours.
- The deepest lake in the US, in a collapsed volcano
- One of the most vividly coloured lakes anywhere
- Rim Drive views of Wizard Island
Head to head
| What matters | Lake Tahoe | Crater Lake |
|---|---|---|
| Depth Edge: Crater Lake | 1,645 ft (501 m) — second-deepest in the US. | 594 m (about 1,950 ft) — the deepest in the US. |
| Size Edge: Lake Tahoe | 22 miles long, 11 miles wide, 192 square miles. | A single caldera lake seen whole from the rim. |
| How it formed Edge: Toss-up | A basin about 2 million years old, fed by 63 streams and drained by the Truckee River. | The caldera left when Mount Mazama collapsed about 7,700 years ago; no inflow or outflow. |
| Getting to the water Edge: Lake Tahoe | Beaches and shore towns all around; at Emerald Bay a 1-mile trail drops 500 ft to Vikingsholm. | Only the steep Cleetwood Cove trail, the one legal way down, and a hard climb back. |
| Season Edge: Lake Tahoe | Year-round recreation; summer for swimming. | Short summer season (roughly July–September); most of the Rim Drive is snowbound the rest of the year. |
| Getting there Edge: Toss-up | Highway 89 along the west shore; Emerald Bay is 22 miles south of Tahoe City. | About 2h–2h30 by road from Medford, about 1h30 from Klamath Falls. |
| Fees Edge: Toss-up | Day-use and parking fees at Emerald Bay State Park — confirm with California State Parks. | National park entrance fee. |
| Time needed Edge: Toss-up | A day for Emerald Bay and a shore drive; longer for a lake holiday. | A day for the Rim Drive and a viewpoint or two. |
Which should you choose?
Choose Lake Tahoe if…
…you want to swim, paddle or base yourself somewhere with lodging and restaurants, or you're travelling outside the summer months.
Choose Crater Lake if…
…you want to see the deepest, bluest lake in the country from a volcanic rim, and can go between July and September.
The honest verdict
For the single most striking colour and a volcano story, Crater Lake — but plan for summer, when the Rim Drive is open, and expect the lake to be something you mostly look at.
For a lake you can actually spend time in and around, Lake Tahoe. Start at Emerald Bay, and remember the water stays cold even in summer.
Wonders mentioned here
Lake Tahoe
Sierra Nevada on the California–Nevada border, USA; Emerald Bay State Park is on the west shore, 22 miles south of Tahoe City
Added